Yet the secondary market is far from a panacea
"Liquidity is the conversion of assets to cash," says Cara Griffiths, Managing Director, GP Strategic Capital Investment Team, at Blue Owl Capital. "In the absence of exits, the focus has tended to be on tools, such as continuation vehicles, net asset value (NAV) loans and secondaries. But the secondary market is worth just 5% of the overall market – it is not a liquidity solution, and it is not a silver bullet."
There will need to be some pain if the system is to be unblocked
"There is massive unrealised NAV stuck in the industry," says Lyon. "NAV loans and GP-led deals are not a blanket solution to this problem. At the end of the day, there probably needs to be some sort of private equity revaluation and some people will need to exit the ecosystem because the industry was overcapitalised. That doesn't mean it's dead; it's just cyclical."
Even so, GP-led deals may actually come into play here – although transactions here could be more along the lines of those that originally spawned today's continuation vehicles. "Some GPs are really challenged in raising new money," says Nicolas. "I've heard of a GP that is looking to put all its assets into a continuation fund because it won't raise another fund. So maybe these types of transaction will come back."
Philipp Patschkowski, Managing Director at Neuberger Berman, agrees. "I can see a scenario where there are more of the fund restructuring deals on the market of the type we saw 15 years ago because of the fundraising environment," he says. "Some GPs won't raise another fund as their performance doesn't stack up and they have become misaligned with their LPs. They might be tempted to move all the assets they have left into a continuation fund and sell at hugely discounted pricing. They may not be great investment opportunities, but there is a scenario where more of these deals come to market."